Informal Physical Evaluation Board

A forum for discussing the Informal Physical Evaluation Board. Includes evidence, appeals and tips.

IPEB Q & A

Q: I have a question about compensation? A: See this: Compensation Q & A Q: What is my chances to get xx% compensation? A: The serverity of your condition/how many unfitting conditions are submitted/whoever does your boar/what is in your records. It would be a guess on my part at best. Q: I received a military rating < 30%, should I appeal? A: I would, you have nothing to loose, even if they rate you as 0% your severance pay will be the same. Q: I received a military rating > 30%, should I appeal? A: Well you can, however they could drop you below 30% and then you will only receive severance pay.In these cases, you should look at the evidence carefully and decide if the benefits outweigh the risks. (Admins: edit/add as...
  • Locked
  • Sticky
View full article »

Fighting PDRL

Hello, I was just taken off of TDRL and placed on PDRL for PTSD. I have only been out for about 6 months and want to try to fight to return to AD. What steps do I need to take to be found fit for duty. I have been attending treatment but I’ve only been going for a couple months and feel like I haven’t had adequate time to prove any improvement in just a few months. It’s Friday so I can’t get anyone on the phone. Does anyone have any experience with a formal PEB hearing or know what steps I need to take to give myself the best chance at success? I have been honest with the VA so far but I have been going through treatment and I feel that I can return if I am given more time at least on tdrl to continue to work to get better.
View full article »

Change in PEBLO

So I guess I am not the only one that has had a change in their PEBLO while in the process. My packet was sent to the PEB on 28 JAN and my boss the other day just asked if I could reach up for a quick status update from my PEBLO as he is trying to backfill my position, but can't do so until a hard date is known on when I will complete this process. So I reached out and thought it odd that I hadn't heard anything back in over a week. Even the no update response, so I reached out to the main office today and was told that my PEBLO transferred overseas and I was assigned a new PEBLO. I am glad I reached out as I don't want to waste time contacting someone who won't be able to help. My question is will this slow down my timeline at all? It...
View full article »

Lower DOD % than expected? Affects on CRSC?

Hello all, Looking for some help as I’ve gotten some conflicting answers on this and I’m trying to prepare as I wait to receive my 199 with the proposed DOD percentage. My VA is proposed at 100% according to my MSC. I’m very thankful; however, my IDES lawyer at Ft Bliss estimated my unfitting DOD percentage to be around 50% based solely on my DBQ. I had a horrible C&P exam and the DBQ doesn’t line up with the historical records in my file. I inquired about differences between 50 and 70% and the lawyer advised she sees no financial link between these. Most of my VA conditions are combat related so I am hoping to pursue CRSC. Would it be worth the fight and extending my time in service to escalate a review to pursue 70%? I am also...
View full article »

IPEB hasnt sent unfit to the VA

Good morning yall, Hoping someone could offer me insight on what tree i need to shake to keep the process moving forward. My case timeline for the IPEB is below: Nov 18 2024: IPEB submitted, MyFSS email received Nov 22 2024: IPEB found unfit (per what My peblo can see) Dec 30th 2024: called the VA to see if there's any guess on when I might hear everything back, they said they are just waiting on the IPEBs fit/unfit decision I've tried to give Jeff a call but don't exactly want to blow up his phone as I'm AF and from what I understand he's navy PEB, but I want to see if there's any way I can get the process moving again. Any help would be much appreciated!
View full article »

Is 100% DOD worth the fight?

Got a proposed rating of 80% and PDRL from TDRL IPEB 1.5 years in - pulled it off myfss site so idk how valid it is as I havent gotten official notification. 70% MDD, 30% Chrons - basically no change from day they TDRL'd me. Thing is VA reevaluated me as 100% MDD/PTSD last Fall and arguably my Chrons is currently in remission so would be like 10% realistically if looked at again based of current VARSD. Spoke with disability attorney over a year ago about TDRL and was informed that DOD must match VA rating if member was reevaluated by VA within 18 months of being reevaluated by DOD - according the secretary of the branch. If they threw away Chrons for military purposes that still puts me at 100% dod based of MH rating - catch is they...
View full article »

Timeline and va memo

I signed my NARSUM Dec 10 2024 and have had a couple of updates when I ask my PEBLO, it was with vote2 on the 27th of jan and then on the 28th of Jan 25 it was showing a status of preparing va memo. Does anyone know what that means and how long I might be looking at from here for a decision and separation? Active army.
View full article »

STR Certification Question

Hey all, I just received a DD Form 2963 in my TOL documents that states: "AFTER SEARCHING WITH ALL DUE DILLIGENCE WITHIN THE TIME FRAME PERMITTED IT IS DETERMINED THAT THE SERVICE TREATMENT RECORD IS MISSING PARTS OR ABSENT." Is this common for AGR Soldiers seeking care from a primary care doctor in the civilian sector? I am assuming so, but wanted some feedback from the group on what this may mean for my claims process portion of the MEB/PEB. I have submitted all my civilian medical records and they are loaded in TOL so I am not sure what else I would need to provide at this point. Thanks for the assistance!
View full article »

IPEB - Medical Retirement vs Medical Separation

Starting the MEB process at just over 13 years due to a referral based on Celiac disease and, soon, a formal diagnosis for frequent/chronic migraines. I am trying to prepare myself for what is next after having served and planned to serve to 20. I am already INDEF with the Army but am planning to be separated. How does the board make a determination to separate vs. medically retire a service member and, is there anything my command or I can do to help push for a retirement? Really depressed with the whole situation as thought I had 7 years left... Thanks in advance.
View full article »

If the VA is Involved Does That Mean Unfit?

Hi everyone, Long-term lurker - this forum has been great to get a pulse on a process that otherwise feels a stress inducing black hole that sort of hovers in the back of your mind. I was referred to PEB on the 10th of September and my PEBLO says that my case is currently at the VA (also confirmed when calling the VA on Monday - rating team assigned, no rater). I've seen conflicting statements on this, but if the VA is involved, does that mean you have been found unfit by the board? Or, is the VA always involved to issue ratings, regardless of the board's decision? (If it matters, I am in the Navy).
View full article »

NDDES and Code 37 issues

I have a Air Force SM (reservist/IMA) who was found NILOD for service-disqualifying conditions and was entered into the NDDES years ago. SM has reached HYT and has no possibility of medical retirement or returning to service. SM has been non-participatory for years, but refuses to retire. They are also refusing to provide updated documents to the PEBLO/MTF. A code 37 was stopping the member from being discharged, but it appears to have dropped off (likely an error on the part of the MTF). What option/s do we have here to get this non-participating SM off the books? AFRC/SG has said this is a personnel issue, but the personnel side won't do anything due to the code 37. Now that it has dropped, is there any legal requirement for the MTF...
View full article »

USAR Reservists LOD Denied MEDBOARD Denied

LOD was denied. Not in Line of Duty Determination goes against issued Army medical opinion and disregards facts-skips a year of my medical records and treatment. My Nurse Case Manager states I can retire or request an informal PEB. Questions. Am I entitled to a PEBLO during an informal PEB? Can I fight the LOD determination? Can my MEBOARD be reinstated if my LOD become In Line of Duty? Even after retiring? Thank you all.
View full article »

Delayed MYFSS Email Air Force

Air Force I signed my narsum Nov 1 and got Myfss notification really late on Dec 10 from what I've seen on this forum it usually takes 3 days or less than a week to get it. Does that mean my peblo just forgot to send it to AFPC. Here's an example of the email. The PEBLO at your MTF sent your MEB package to the Air Force Personnel Center Physical Disability Operations Branch.
View full article »

Medical Board Questions, help!

Hi there. I am currently active duty in the Navy. I was sea duty then was transfered to shore duty on limdu orders, now i have been put on a med board. My background: Im currenlty in the beginning process of my medical board. I was recommended for a medical board with "Major Depression" and "Anxiety" . Unfortunatley, I experienced a misscarriage Feb 2019. My misscarriage triggered me to go into a depressive state. I was no longer able to focus, i was having mood swings, i was having troubles concentrating at work and i started having sleep issues. I became reclusive, i no longer had intrest in activities i once loved. I started having relationship problems with my husband to the point where we almost seperated. i felt so alone and i...
View full article »

Referred conditions, (I want 20%)

TLDR; I don’t want the 30% dod I want 20% or less. So I’ve been on a meb for awhile for some back surgeries for 3 lumbar disc herniations, ddd, spinal stenosis and all that for awhile. My form 4 for the MEB only had 1 referred condition of DDD. Yesterday I went in to sign my 618 for the PEB, it read as DDD with Radiculopathy as referred conditions. My dqb noted it in both legs as moderate/severe. Here’s the weird part. I don’t want med retirement. I want the severance. Why? The company I’ve signed a contract to hire with who Im skill bridging with has great insurance and as well as great pay (software dev stuff). I want the severance bc I’m at 13.5 years rn in service and the severance will be over 100k. I could really use that to...
View full article »

Awaiting signature on da 199

My case is at the PEB. My PEBLO told me what my DOD rating is, already know my VA. She said it’s written and can see it but it is awaiting final approval. Question is, how freakin long does this take? It’s been sitting in that same status for 3 weeks. Can my DOD ratings change during that stage? Thanks - just tired of waiting and anxious as hell to sign it and get orders.
View full article »

PEB Help

I spoke with the VA today asking about the status of my claim and they stated they are waiting on the PEB to find me fit or unfit before they are able to finalize and propose a rating. Does this sound right to you all? Does anyone know an approximate timeline as to when the PEB will contact the VA? My case has been with the VA DRAS since 9/4.
View full article »

PEB Vote

I'm looking to compile information into one place about the PEB voting process, as there's a lot of conflicting information out there. Here's what I've complied so far: 1) 3 Person Board, consisting of 1 Line Officer (I'm guessing for service impact determinations?), 1 medical professional (agree or disagree with MEBAA?) and presiding officer that acts as a tiebreaker if needed. 2) Service impacts are considered. Potentially, there's communications on if someone would be mandatory retainable for any positions via the various personnel management commands? 3) The packages are reviewed individually and determinations based upon the role of the board member are made. 4) The timelines vary SIGNIFICANTLY from a couple days to multiple...
View full article »
Need help preparing for FPEB board

Need help preparing for FPEB board

Hello, I have received a 10% DOD evaluation for neuralgia and neuritis unspecified (stable) diagnostic code 8526, but this is not the case. This rating also comes with pelvic and perennial pain as a secondary it also says stable. This rating was given to me through the DOD through the IDES process, but my doctor does not agree with this rating, nor do I. The doctor that completed my NARSUM (also my doctor who has seen me over the last year who is an active duty doctor at a Naval hospital) has reviewed my records, and stated that my pelvic and perennial pain is uncontrollable and not stable, which warrants a 30% rating under diagnostic code 7629. I elected for a FPEB board to challenge this DOD rating and my doctor has written an IDES...
View full article »

Exam information does not match what I've stated, nor my medical record.

Good afternoon, everyone, I'm just posting this to get some opinions and possibly an answer to a question. During the exam for my TBI, the doc marked everything as "Normal" and proceeded to say that I have no discernable memory issues or cognitive impairment. While both myself and my history with Neurology would state otherwise, pretty aggressively. The question I'm proposing is, am I able to have my TBI re-assessed after I leave the military and my medboard is completed? I would really like to avoid a formal board if I can, due to the fact I'd like to get out of here. I have a lot of medical issues that are affecting my ability to work and be a productive member of my team. Not only that but I would like to leave so I can properly...
View full article »
You must log in or register to post here.

Online statistics

Members online
2
Guests online
63
Total visitors
65
Totals may include hidden visitors.

Forum statistics

Threads
39,623
Messages
275,316
Members
84,502
Latest member
Cooper10C5
Top