Jason Perry
Founder and Leader
Site Founder
Staff Member
PEB Forum Veteran
Lifetime Supporter
Registered Member
Press Release from the VA:
VA and DoD Pilot Single Physical
November 7, 2007
“This agreement commits VA and DoD to develop a single process to assess the medical conditions of wounded, injured or ill service members,” said Acting Secretary of Veterans Affairs Gordon H. Mansfield. “We will make it easier for these heroes to go back to their homes, with the key questions about their eligibility for VA compensation already decided.”
The agreement, signed Nov. 6 by Mansfield and Dr. David S.C. Chu, Under Secretary of Defense for Personnel and Readiness, calls for a pilot program to evaluate a single physical examination that would be used by DoD to determine the medical fitness of injured personnel to remain in uniform and by VA for awarding disability compensation.
Today’s announcement continues progress on the recommendations of the President’s Commission on Care for America’s Returning Wounded Warriors, co-chaired by former Sen. Robert Dole and former Health and Human Services Secretary Donna Shalala.
The pilot, which begins late this month, involves VA and DoD facilities in Washington, D.C. Service members from the Walter Reed Army Medical Center, the National Naval Medical Center in Bethesda, and the Air Force’s Malcolm Grow Medical Center at Andrews Air Force Base will participate in the pilot.
Medical evaluations will be performed by VA, although the agreement notes the physicals could actually take place in VA medical centers, military installations, VA contracted examination centers or other facilities.
The memorandum says the process “lays the foundation for building a network of qualified providers and resources that will meet both DoD and VA requirements and ease the transition of members from military service to veteran status.”
The evaluations will be based upon VA’s system for disability examinations and include an examination of medical conditions identified by military physicians that call into question a service member’s fitness for duty, as well as other applicable medical conditions identified by the service member together with VA. "
It will be interesting to see how this plays out. There is still a lot of controversy over what reform will look like. Dole-Shalala recommendations have a lot of supporters, however, VDBC has come up with different recommendations. With Chairman of Senate Committee on Veterans Affairs, Sen, Akaka voicing doubts on Dole-Shalala, I think it is still in up in the air how this plays out.
This is just a pilot program, so most cases are going to be processed normally. One interesting question will be if there will be a relationship between a challenge to the exam on the VA side impacting a rating or an appeal on the DOD side. I would think that if both systems use the same exam, a succesful challenge to the sufficiency of the exam in one system should impact the decision in the other system. Not necessarily so, but it will be interesting how this is dealt with.
VA and DoD Pilot Single Physical
November 7, 2007
One Exam Used for “Fitness for Duty” and Disability Pay
WASHINGTON – In a landmark agreement to simplify life for service members with medical problems as they leave the military and return to the civilian world, the Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) and the Department of Defense (DoD) signed a memorandum to pilot a single physical examination to be used by both Departments.“This agreement commits VA and DoD to develop a single process to assess the medical conditions of wounded, injured or ill service members,” said Acting Secretary of Veterans Affairs Gordon H. Mansfield. “We will make it easier for these heroes to go back to their homes, with the key questions about their eligibility for VA compensation already decided.”
The agreement, signed Nov. 6 by Mansfield and Dr. David S.C. Chu, Under Secretary of Defense for Personnel and Readiness, calls for a pilot program to evaluate a single physical examination that would be used by DoD to determine the medical fitness of injured personnel to remain in uniform and by VA for awarding disability compensation.
Today’s announcement continues progress on the recommendations of the President’s Commission on Care for America’s Returning Wounded Warriors, co-chaired by former Sen. Robert Dole and former Health and Human Services Secretary Donna Shalala.
The pilot, which begins late this month, involves VA and DoD facilities in Washington, D.C. Service members from the Walter Reed Army Medical Center, the National Naval Medical Center in Bethesda, and the Air Force’s Malcolm Grow Medical Center at Andrews Air Force Base will participate in the pilot.
Medical evaluations will be performed by VA, although the agreement notes the physicals could actually take place in VA medical centers, military installations, VA contracted examination centers or other facilities.
The memorandum says the process “lays the foundation for building a network of qualified providers and resources that will meet both DoD and VA requirements and ease the transition of members from military service to veteran status.”
The evaluations will be based upon VA’s system for disability examinations and include an examination of medical conditions identified by military physicians that call into question a service member’s fitness for duty, as well as other applicable medical conditions identified by the service member together with VA. "
It will be interesting to see how this plays out. There is still a lot of controversy over what reform will look like. Dole-Shalala recommendations have a lot of supporters, however, VDBC has come up with different recommendations. With Chairman of Senate Committee on Veterans Affairs, Sen, Akaka voicing doubts on Dole-Shalala, I think it is still in up in the air how this plays out.
This is just a pilot program, so most cases are going to be processed normally. One interesting question will be if there will be a relationship between a challenge to the exam on the VA side impacting a rating or an appeal on the DOD side. I would think that if both systems use the same exam, a succesful challenge to the sufficiency of the exam in one system should impact the decision in the other system. Not necessarily so, but it will be interesting how this is dealt with.