Hello everyone! If you are reading this thread, thank you!
I finally got my findings back, and I now have a week left to decide whether or not to finalize. I'm currently out of state (from the Naval base where my PEB is being handled), and will not return until the day before I have to give the PEBLO my decision. As such, legal counsel is out of the question, and I thought this would be the next best place to get a second opinion.
First off, my findings:
The PEB only received Persistent Depressive Disorder and BPD as my board-able conditions. As a result, they have found me UNFIT, Not-Rated, and to Separate w/o Additional Benefits.
The VA also received said disorders, along with various physical ailments, and rated me at 80%. My initial thought, as well as that of friends and families I turned to for advice, was that I should accept the findings and move on with my life.
On to my questions:
1. Would it be worth contesting my findings? I have heard and read that requesting a formal hearing can backfire, because the PEB takes a closer look at your submission, and you may end up shooting yourself in the foot (figuratively). Furthermore, based on circumstances and symptoms of Military Disability Ratings, the best I could hope for is 10% (for my Persistent DD). Am I correct in that assessment?
2. Other than word-of-mouth, I have very little new evidence to provide to the board, other than the narrative my providers had already submitted for the first go-around.
3. If the VA found my disabilities to be service-aggravated (hence, the 80%), is it likely the DoD will change their mind as well, since they decided it was pre-existing and not service-connected?
4. My PEBLO did not counsel me on TDRL requirements, and it is marked as "N/A" on my PEB Counseling Checklist. Does that mean I am in the PDRL camp? I could not find anything in the findings package that reflected either or.
If you've gotten this far, thank you for reading! I appreciate any and all advice you all can provide.
I finally got my findings back, and I now have a week left to decide whether or not to finalize. I'm currently out of state (from the Naval base where my PEB is being handled), and will not return until the day before I have to give the PEBLO my decision. As such, legal counsel is out of the question, and I thought this would be the next best place to get a second opinion.
First off, my findings:
The PEB only received Persistent Depressive Disorder and BPD as my board-able conditions. As a result, they have found me UNFIT, Not-Rated, and to Separate w/o Additional Benefits.
The VA also received said disorders, along with various physical ailments, and rated me at 80%. My initial thought, as well as that of friends and families I turned to for advice, was that I should accept the findings and move on with my life.
On to my questions:
1. Would it be worth contesting my findings? I have heard and read that requesting a formal hearing can backfire, because the PEB takes a closer look at your submission, and you may end up shooting yourself in the foot (figuratively). Furthermore, based on circumstances and symptoms of Military Disability Ratings, the best I could hope for is 10% (for my Persistent DD). Am I correct in that assessment?
2. Other than word-of-mouth, I have very little new evidence to provide to the board, other than the narrative my providers had already submitted for the first go-around.
3. If the VA found my disabilities to be service-aggravated (hence, the 80%), is it likely the DoD will change their mind as well, since they decided it was pre-existing and not service-connected?
4. My PEBLO did not counsel me on TDRL requirements, and it is marked as "N/A" on my PEB Counseling Checklist. Does that mean I am in the PDRL camp? I could not find anything in the findings package that reflected either or.
If you've gotten this far, thank you for reading! I appreciate any and all advice you all can provide.