Worried about my MEB process. Things feel fishy and I would like some input.

thanks4urhelp

Well-Known Member
PEB Forum Veteran
Registered Member
I'm on a medboard for the following referred conditions (USMC if that matters, 1 year and some change TIS, no disciplinary history, 21 & married)

"M5450 - Low back pain, unspecified
M546 - Pain in thoracic spine" - MEB report unfitting conditions.

NARSUM: "SM had a fall during hike in October 2022 during comm-electronics training and was placed on light duty for 90 days before being placed on LIMDU in May2023. He was initially treated with physical therapy after XR revealed transitional anatomy at T12 which was unhelpful. He was referred to chiropractor which was unhelpful. He was trialed on amitriptyline, duloxetine which was not helpful. MRI Lumbar and thoracic spine 19JUL2023 revealed T6-T8 degenerative changes with mild spinal canal narrowing at T6-7 and dorsal epidural lipomatosis in the upper/mid thoracic spine. Of note, these findings do not explain pain involving multiple segments of upper and lower back. He was referred to pain mgmt and behavioral health with treatments including acceptance and commitment therapy and is has not been helpful. ESR/CRP, RA and SLE lab screening was negative for inflammatory arthropathy. He was evaluated by neurosurgery who does not see any surgical indication. Overall, SM has 12 months of chronic back pain without correlative objective evidence and lack of improvement to all modalities to date. He is unable to perform the duties of his MOS including maintaining USMC standards with CFT/PFT."

A prior PEBLO who is running an insider advice program free of charge to junior enlisted advised me that it's hard to get 30% or above for these referred conditions. My forward flexion is estimated at its highest 20 degrees from physical therapy, and 10 degrees by my sports med doc. From what I understand, this should align with the 40% rating, being 30 degrees forward flexion or less, dictating ROM without pain. Does this sound right? Am I misguided? That prior PEBLO placed MASSIVE importance on getting 30% DoD, even pushing for me to try to get anxiety added into my MEB.

MRI revealed bulging disc + disc protrusion in thoracic spine from a hiking injury for context.

The part I'm worried about is that I was referred to IDES, only to be told it'll be a 3 month wait to be found fit/unfit (I was told 3 month wait to be "accepted" by the PEB. Worried that this is a game. Again that PEBLO told me that this wait time is abnormal. My contact rep (guy I was told to contact before I contact my real PEBLO) told me he has no updates for me at this time.

Perspectives would be great, especially if anyone knows how the C&P exam for back pain goes/what I should expect rating wise.

Relevant MRI results:

Thoracic spine:
Alignment: Normal
Marrow: Mild degenerative endplate bone marrow edema seen at T6-T7. Small hemangioma noted in the T3 vertebral body anteriorly.
Spinal cord: Normal in signal.
Mildly prominent dorsal epidural fat is seen in the upper/mid thoracic spine, greatest at T6-17.
Pertinent levels are as follows:
T6-T7: Disc desiccation with small central disc protrusion measuring 2 mm, which mildly indents the ventral cord. There is mild spinal canal narrowing. No foraminal narrowing.
T7-T8: Disc desiccation with mild diffuse disc bulge. No spinal canal or foraminal narrowing.

I spoke to a neurosurgeon who saw no surgical indication on my back, and reasoned that my issue must be muscular in nature. My doc thinks it could be fibromyalgia. Board began late October if that matters as well.
 
It is hard to be found unfit for back pain at greater than or equal to 30%. Start now learning everything you can about the process. You may want to consult with an attorney to plan your path.
 
Last edited:
It is hard to be found unfit for back pain. Start now learning everything you can about the process. You may want to consult with an attorney to plan your path.
I've considered going to base legal, but outside attorneys aren't willing to help until I'm able to contest my ratings which is obviously way past that point. Nobody, to include all of my docs, seem to think I will be found fit and have told me to just prep for the after military life. I've been warned junior enlisted tend to get screwed hard with this stuff, that's why I'm being very cautious.
 
I've considered going to base legal, but outside attorneys aren't willing to help until I'm able to contest my ratings which is obviously way past that point. Nobody, to include all of my docs, seem to think I will be found fit and have told me to just prep for the after military life. I've been warned junior enlisted tend to get screwed hard with this stuff, that's why I'm being very cautious.
Not sure what outside attorneys you are talking to but the good ones will work with you well beforehand. It's much harder to change the result at the end than being proactive early in the process. I will send you some references via direct chat.
 
It is hard to be found unfit for back pain at greater than or equal to 30%. Start now learning everything you can about the process. You may want to consult with an attorney to plan your path.
I’m new to all this too as the OP, but I see you’re not. Can’t other conditions, assuming they are service limiting, be pulled into that DoD rating if the MEB believes it should be considered.
 
Absolutely yes, but it is one of those things that doesn't appear to happen with regularity at the Informal PEB.
 
Absolutely yes, but it is one of those things that doesn't appear to happen with regularity at the Informal PEB.
Follow up question, you mentioned that it is difficult to be found unfit for back pain which confused me.

Where does this difficulty come into play? My PCM was so certain this was open and shut he didn't even allow for a second term of LIMDU. Curious what made you say this as I've only heard it is significantly more difficult to get a "high rating" for back pain. The way it's been described to me seems relatively simple, with overarching diagnoses not playing much effect unless they cascade. On ROM alone I was told I should expect 40% given my findings in sports med and physical therapy rom estimated being well within that threshold.
 
Follow up question, you mentioned that it is difficult to be found unfit for back pain which confused me.

Where does this difficulty come into play? My PCM was so certain this was open and shut he didn't even allow for a second term of LIMDU. Curious what made you say this as I've only heard it is significantly more difficult to get a "high rating" for back pain. The way it's been described to me seems relatively simple, with overarching diagnoses not playing much effect unless they cascade. On ROM alone I was told I should expect 40% given my findings in sports med and physical therapy rom estimated being well within that threshold.
Muscle skeleton issues do not get rated high. You however can have radiculopathy/peripheal nerves that can boost you. I rated a lumbar-sacral the other day,
 
I am in a similar situation. I have multiple conditions that I believe are unfitting; including conditions that I am already rated for. The only condition I was referred for was my lower back. I was considering starting another thread asking if DOD will look at the other non referred conditions. My other conditions are covered very well with documentation, LODs, etc, and are prominent on my Commander's Statement.

It's apparent that the DOD does not care about pain associated with spinal conditions. I believe the associated pain is the biggest factor in back injuries.
 
Absolutely yes, but it is one of those things that doesn't appear to happen with regularity at the Informal PEB.
When would other conditions be pulled into the OP’s case as referred conditions if deemed as service limiting? Prior to the NARSUM but after the initial C&P exams? Or a separate time? Should he go ahead and submit for an IMR to add more referred conditions if they’re there? I'm clearly uneducated but am starting this process myself and just looking for clarity.
 
I am in a similar situation. I have multiple conditions that I believe are unfitting; including conditions that I am already rated for. The only condition I was referred for was my lower back. I was considering starting another thread asking if DOD will look at the other non referred conditions. My other conditions are covered very well with documentation, LODs, etc, and are prominent on my Commander's Statement.

It's apparent that the DOD does not care about pain associated with spinal conditions. I believe the associated pain is the biggest factor in back injuries.
Can you explain the latter portion of your assertion a bit more? I don't think I understood correctly.

You say "...the DOD does not care about pain associated with spinal conditions." and later assert "...associated pain is the biggest factor..." this confuses me and reads as the same thing in my eyes.

My boarding reason was that I cannot do the fitness tests required of me based on my chronic pain. I would assume that's reason enough but I'm curious to hear your thoughts.
 
When would other conditions be pulled into the OP’s case as referred conditions if deemed as service limiting? Prior to the NARSUM but after the initial C&P exams? Or a separate time? Should he go ahead and submit for an IMR to add more referred conditions if they’re there? I'm clearly uneducated but am starting this process myself and just looking for clarity.
I'd wait for his response as well, but I've been told any further modification of a MEB is handled at the formal stage. I'm doing my best to get a formal diagnosis for fibromyalgia since I've gotten treatment for it. The most my PCM is willing to do is give me medication and explicitly write that "Subject Marine is under approved treatment for fibromyalgia." I'd presume the formal stage is after the informal decision, which is after everything you described.
 
Can you explain the latter portion of your assertion a bit more? I don't think I understood correctly.

You say "...the DOD does not care about pain associated with spinal conditions." and later assert "...associated pain is the biggest factor..." this confuses me and reads as the same thing in my eyes.

My boarding reason was that I cannot do the fitness tests required of me based on my chronic pain. I would assume that's reason enough but I'm curious to hear your thoughts.
What I meant was, DOD ratings are based on ROM and not perceived pain and I feel it is a disservice to the service member to not factor in pain for fit/unfit and ratings.
 
What I meant was, DOD ratings are based on ROM and not perceived pain and I feel it is a disservice to the service member to not factor in pain for fit/unfit and ratings.
I agree with that. Though limitation of ROM due to pain is acceptable for ratings from what I've seen on DBQ explanations and the like.
 
When would other conditions be pulled into the OP’s case as referred conditions if deemed as service limiting? Prior to the NARSUM but after the initial C&P exams? Or a separate time? Should he go ahead and submit for an IMR to add more referred conditions if they’re there? I'm clearly uneducated but am starting this process myself and just looking for clarity.
The easy answer is Google conditions secondary to (your referred disease).
Then ask your doctor what diseases might be secondary.
Learn about your disease from a reputable website
Like American Heart Association …
Consult with MEB counsel as to that road bumps are normal for your referred condition and what evidence to gather for the formal PEB, if necessary.
 
Just wanted to post this here since I found it insightful about secondary conditions:

 
Top